Skip to content

Protection and reliability depth

What the protection engineer and the reliability analyst ask for after the time-current plot and the SAIFI/SAIDI study. Everything here runs from Studies → Protection and the Reliability tab.

Faults anywhere on a line

Fault on a line splits a chosen line at a chosen fraction of its length in the compiled model, places a fault there — three-phase, line-to-ground, line-to-line or double-line-to-ground, through a resistance for the ground cases — and solves. It reports the current in the fault and the current every protective device carries. POST /api/faultline is the route; POST /api/faultpoint does the same at a bus.

Reach

Check every device's reach finds, for every fuse, recloser and relay, the buses of its protection section and the minimum fault current among them: line-to-line bolted and line-to-ground through the resistance given (20 Ω by default), from Fault-element solves. That against the device's phase pickup (and its ground pickup against the line-to-ground case) is the reach ratio; below 1.5 × pickup the device may not see the fault at the end of its zone, and the row is flagged. DER in the zone feeds the fault too, so the device sees less of it: the DER's contribution (1.2 × rated current for inverters, 5 × for a machine) is taken off, and both figures are shown.

Fuse saving and fuse blowing

Grade every recloser–fuse pair. For each fuse with a recloser above it: at the maximum fault at the fuse (the fault study's three-phase value) the recloser's fast curve must operate before the fuse melts — the fuse-saving test; at the minimum fault at the end of the fuse's zone the fuse must clear before the recloser's delayed curve — the fuse-blowing test. Total clearing time comes from the fuse's Total-clear curve when it has one (a second curve, added like any other in the Curves tab), else from its melting time times 1.15. Each pair says which tests it passes and why not.

Sectionalizers and reclose intervals

A breaker ticked Sectionalizer opens during the upstream recloser's dead time after counting fault interruptions; it carries no curve and never interrupts fault current itself. OpenDSS has no class for it, so for the reliability sections it heads it compiles as a relay with a pickup nothing reaches — the EnergyMeter counts it as a section boundary, the coordination study leaves it out. A recloser's Reclose intervals (a list of seconds, e.g. 0.5, 2, 5) are written as the engine's recloseintervals.

Settings sheet

The report's protection section gained a Settings table, in the form a relay technician reads: pickup in primary amps and as a multiple of the device's continuous rating, curves, time dial (added delay), fast operations and shots to lockout, reclose intervals, interrupting rating.

Reliability indices

The Reliability tab and report add to SAIFI, SAIDI and CAIDI:

Index What it is
MAIFI Momentary interruptions per customer per year: the temporary share of each recloser-headed section's faults (fault rate less the permanent share) interrupts every customer below the recloser. Fuses and relays make every fault sustained
ASAI Availability, 1 − SAIDI/8760
CEMI₁, ₂, ₃, ₅ The share of customers whose expected sustained interruptions a year exceed 1, 2, 3 or 5. The expectation, not a random draw: every load sees the permanent faults of its own section and of every section above it
ASIFI SAIFI weighted by load kW instead of customers
Outage cost Customer interruption cost: per sustained interruption and per customer-hour by load class (residential, commercial, industrial; a default for the rest), order-of-magnitude figures in the range of the US DOE ICE Calculator. Replace them with the utility's own

Where a recloser helps most

Try a recloser on each line places a recloser mid-way on each candidate line in turn (longest first, up to forty), reruns the reliability study and ranks the lines by the fall in SAIDI and the customer-hours saved. It is the number that justifies the spend.

What has been checked

tests/test_m16.py holds: a fault half-way along a line sits between the currents at its two ends and every upstream device carries it; the reach study finds every device's minimum fault and ranks the weakest reach first, and DER in a fuse's zone lowers what the fuse sees; the recloser–fuse pair is graded both ways from the curves; the recloser placement ranks by the SAIDI fall; a sectionalizer heads a reliability section without appearing in the TCC plot and reclose intervals compile; MAIFI, ASAI, CEMI, ASIFI and the outage cost come out of the study, and a feeder with no recloser has no momentary interruptions.